Darkness

"Oh the headache again. I swear it's these symbols..."This article does not meet Destinypedia's standards. You can help by cleaning this article.

"Vex encryption. Unbreakable? Ha, so they say."This article does not have enough inline references. You can help Destinypedia by adding citations.
For more information, see the citation policy.

Darkness
Biographical information
Other name(s):	"The Deep" "Clarity" "Luster"
Species:	Paracausal force
Political and military information
Affiliation:	Champions Hive (Worm Gods) Vex (Black Heart, Sol Divisive, Sol Progeny) Taken (Ascendant Realm) Scorn (Dark Ether) The Witness (Precursors, The Dread, Nightmares, The Veil, Black Fleet) Fallen (Splinter of Darkness, House of Salvation) Cabal (Loyalists, Red Legion, Shadow Legion) Humanity (Stasis, Strand, Clovis Bray, Neomuna)

"Darkness is not inherently evil. Some among you already discovered this on Europa. In my travels, I have seen true evil. It is the worm gods that the Hive serve. It is the Black Fleet, waiting to strike. It is the Entity that commands them all: the Voice in the Darkness."

— Mara Sov

The Darkness, also known as the Deep, is a paracausal force associated with the Veil. It serves as one of two fundamental forces of the universe and is the opposing counterpart to the Light.

Overview

Like the Light, the Darkness is a cosmic paracausal force that has existed since before the beginning of time. Similarly to the Light, it manifests in a variety of aspects, among them elemental powers such as Stasis and Strand.

For centuries following the Collapse, the Darkness was believed by scholars of the Last City to be an inherently evil force, with its usage inevitably corrupting the wielder. This is now known to be untrue: just as the Light can be used for constructive and benevolent purposes as well as destructive and self-serving ones, the act of wielding the Darkness has no moral valence on its own, and it can be used for good or ill. Ancient civilizations such as the Ecumene and the Qugu used the Darkness for peaceful purposes, such as communing with the memories of their ancestors. In contrast, the being known as the Witness and its Disciples, who collectively led the armada known as the Black Fleet and exterminated countless civilizations uplifted by the Traveler, wielded the Darkness as a weapon against their enemies. Most of humanity's knowledge of the Darkness has come from the Collapse and subsequent conflicts with those aligned with the Witness and its cause, such as the Hive, Taken, Scorn and the Vex of the Sol Divisive, which has led to a prevalent but one-sided view of Darkness as a destructive force hostile to life and peaceful civilization.

The nature of the relationship between the Light and Darkness remains somewhat ambiguous. The Witness and its followers clearly believe the Darkness to be superior to the Light and oppose all who would use it, and the Darkness itself is presented in Unveiling as having opposed the Light since before the beginning of time. However, in Inspiral, a slightly more nuanced picture is given in the entry "Winnowing", where the Darkness is portrayed as playing a necessary and complementary role to that of the Light in helping to maintain the stability of life and civilization. After having gained insights into the Darkness from his studies of Strand, Osiris states that the Light and Darkness are not truly antagonistic forces, but merely different.

History

Origins

"Once upon a time,* a gardener and a winnower lived** together in a garden.***
* It was once before a time, because time had not yet begun.
** We did not live. We existed as principles of ontological dynamics that emerged from mathematical structures, as bodiless and inevitable as the primes.
*** It was the field of possibility that prefigured existence."

— Unveiling: Gardener and Winnower

According to the Lore Book "Unveiling," both the Light and the Darkness have existed since before the beginning of time, and thus before the universe came into existence. Being unbound by the laws of causality, neither the Light nor Darkness can be said to have a beginning. Rather, they are emergent properties of even more fundamental "mathematical structures" that in turn underlay reality itself.

In the allegorical story recounted in the Lore Book, the Darkness and the Light are referred to as the "Winnower" and "Gardener" respectively. The Winnower and Gardener occupied themselves by engaging one another in a game, analogous to a vastly more complex version of the "Game of Life" devised by Earth mathematician John Conway. This game would consistently arrive at an end-state dominated by a single, self-perpetuating pattern, which subsumed all others in the game. The Winnower found this to be a pleasing outcome, but the Gardener felt the pattern to be boring and desired that the game endlessly produce novel patterns instead. To promote this novelty, the Gardener transformed itself into a new "rule" within the game; the Winnower did the same, to counteract the Gardener's efforts. These new rules were "set aside" from the other rules of the game, so that they could not be limited or influenced by them, but could manipulate the other rules to bring about their intended outcomes.

While the story above is laden with metaphor and open to interpretation, it appears to suggest that the universe is the "game" that the Light and Darkness played in the garden, that the rules of the game are the laws of physics as they are commonly understood, and that the "new rules" that the Light and Darkness became are the basis of paracausality. The narrator of the Lore Book identifies themself as the Winnower, seemingly indicating that the Darkness, in addition to being a cosmic paracausal force, is sentient and driven by its own goals and motivations.

The Veil

The entity known as the Veil is a powerful source of Darkness and appears to act as a Darkness-affiliated counterpart to the Traveler, with which it is connected. Its origins are unknown, although it is known to have existed for billions of years, predating the Witness and the Black Fleet.

The Witness

A Pyramid

Billions of years ago, a nomadic humanoid species discovered the Traveler lying dormant and half-buried on their homeworld. The Traveler awakened and began to terraform the planet and grant paracausal gifts to the species, uplifting them into a golden age that lasted for millions of years. Despite their prosperity, however, the civilization became dissatisfied with the Traveler's silence and refusal to impart guidance or wisdom, and sought a greater purpose in which they could find meaning; in the words of Ahsa, they desired a "winnower" to shape the otherwise formless garden of their existence. In addition, they came to view the Light as a fundamentally chaotic and capricious force, equally capable of bringing life or death with no ultimate justification for either.

In studying the Traveler, the civilization discovered that it was connected to another entity in a distant star system, which they named "the Veil". They determined that the Veil was the source of a power that was the opposite of the Light, one tied to the mind and consciousness rather than the physical universe: the Darkness. Furthermore, they determined that by bringing the Veil into close proximity with the Traveler, their powers could be used together to reshape reality as they saw fit, enabling them to convert the universe into a perfected, eternal form they called the "Final Shape".

Seeking to achieve this outcome, the civilization traveled to the star system where the Veil was located and brought it back to their homeworld, where the Traveler had remained since its discovery. However, the Traveler responded by leaving the planet and fleeing into the far reaches of space. Unwilling to give up their quest, the civilization used the Darkness to bind their consciousnesses together into a singular, unfathomably powerful entity, which became known as the Witness. This being then left its homeworld with a fleet of pyramidal ships, seeking to find the Traveler and unite it with the Veil by force, and in so doing bring about the Final Shape.

Rise of the Worm Gods

Billions of years ago, a species of aquatic, paracausally-empowered serpentine creatures lived on the planet Fundament, where they led a peaceful existence. However, at some point, they became seduced by the philosophy of the Witness and began to fight and kill each other to achieve ascendancy through the Sword Logic. As they fought, they called upon the Darkness and used it as a weapon, an act once considered unthinkable among their kind. Many of the creatures died in the planet-wide bloodbath that ensued, with at least one individual, Ahsa, managing to escape and leave Fundament entirely; others transformed, becoming the powerful Darkness-aligned entities known as the Worm Gods.

Lubrae's Ruin

Billions of years ago, the Witness visited the planet Lubrae, where it met a young warrior named Rhulk who had become disillusioned with his family and clan following a series of perceived betrayals. The Witness granted Rhulk the use of the Darkness, which would later enable Rhulk to bring about the total annihilation of his own people by causing his homeworld's Sapphiric Sun to implode. Rhulk was subsequently taken in by the Witness and anointed the first of its Disciples.

The Ecumene

The civilization known as the Ecumene were attuned to the Darkness, though they did not seem to share the violent and destructive goals of the Witness and its Disciples, and indeed would later come into conflict with the nascent Hive.

The Qugu

The species known as the Qugu were attuned to the Darkness, and used it to commune with the memories of their ancestors. Much like the Ecumene, they seemed to be a peaceful civilization, in stark contrast to the Darkness' self-proclaimed tenets.

The Birth of the Hive

"Oryx went down into his throne world. He went out into the abyss, and with each step he read one of his tablets, so that they became like stones beneath his feet.
He went out and he created an altar and he prepared an unborn ogre. He called on the Deep, saying:
I can see you in the sky. You are the waves, which are battles, and the battles are the waves. Come into this vessel I have prepared for you.
And it arrived, the Deep Itself."

— The Books of Sorrow, XXXI: Battle made waves

One of the earliest recorded mentions of the Darkness known to the Guardians comes from the Books of Sorrow, a collection of records discovered aboard the Dreadnaught of Oryx, the Taken King. The books describe the origins of the Hive on the gas giant Fundament, where the three daughters of a deposed king, Aurash, Xi Ro, and Sathona, set out to save their world from a prophesied apocalypse. In their quest, they encountered the massive being known as the Leviathan, who warned them against the temptation of "The Deep," a philosophy which held that "existence is the struggle to exist," and which it claimed would lead them only to ruin and calamity. It instead told them to pursue the philosophy of "The Sky," which encouraged collaboration to build a kinder, more prosperous world, even if it meant that some deaths and misfortunes must be allowed to occur. The sisters rejected the Leviathan's advice, and dove deep into the core of their world to find the five Worms: Eir, Ur, Yul, Xol, and Akka.

The Worm Gods promised to lend the sisters their paracausal powers, which they drew from the Deep, in return for the sisters becoming hosts for the Worms' larvae. The sisters agreed and became the founders and God-rulers of what would one day become known as the Hive. The Worms taught the nascent Hive Gods of the Sword Logic, which they used to become ever more powerful.

Much later, the Hive God Auryx (who was once Aurash) slew the Worm God Akka to obtain enough power to learn more about the secrets of the Deep, and in doing so he obtained the power to Take, a power wielded by the Witness. He became thereafter known as Oryx, the Taken King. Sometime later, he sought to commune with the Witness directly and prepared an Ogre as a sacrifice, which the Deep inhabited and used to converse with Oryx.

The Cambrian Explosion

"And then—one day—the fall occurred. So much earlier and so much more necessary than your myths remember. (…) This was the Cambrian Explosion, the great birth of complex life on your world. I caused it. I, the defector, the destroyer, the one who takes."

— Unveiling

According to Unveiling, the Cambrian Explosion (i.e. the rapid appearance and diversification of complex life on Earth) was one of innumerable examples across the history of the universe where the Darkness played a role in bringing about complex life, by virtue of curtailing the existence of weaker organisms and thereby driving biological evolution.

Riis and The Whirlwind

"Where is the Great Machine? Where is the Great Machine?"

— Chelchis, Kell of Stone

At some point during the Golden Age of the Eliksni on Riis, a young Eliksni named Haaksis stole a scout-ship and became lost, eventually finding himself on an abandoned, airless world. He discovered an ancient, abandoned city, at the center of which was a "ship like a blade". Haaksis retrieved a spherical metallic artifact from the city, which spoke to him in his mind and showed him how to find his way home. As Haaksis grew into adulthood, the voice within the artifact continued to speak to him, telling him of the pointless struggle of life, and of an impending doom that would befall the Eliksni.

Years later, Haaksis became a Baron of the House of Rain, and attempted to rid himself of the artifact's visions by casting it away into a river. However, the artifact was swallowed by a local predator known as a "river-catcher," which became corrupted with Darkness and began attacking Haaksis' people. The Slayer Baron Kiiraskes was sent to slay the beast, and upon dispatching the creature, she and her apprentice Irrha discovered the artifact within its remains; upon examining Irrha's memoirs untold centuries later, the scribe Eido of House Light inferred that the object was of the same kind as the mysterious artifact given to the Young Wolf by the Witness during their exploration of the Lunar Pyramid. Kiiraskes later mentioned that Chelchis, Kell of Stone had recently been delivering "strange reports" to the Houses of Kings and Judgment, which Chelchis felt signaled an impending catastrophe; however, Kiiraskes stated that Chelchis believed the true danger would come from within Eliksni civilization, not from the outside.

Some time after this, Riis was attacked by the Witness and its Black Fleet, as well as Oryx's Hive, resulting in a cataclysm became known in Eliksni history as the Whirlwind. As it had so many times before, the Traveler fled Riis rather than face the Black Fleet, and the Eliskni were reduced to a race of interstellar nomads.

Pre-Collapse

"Heaven is invaded and its territories are afire and all its mountains have been shattered into thrones. This is the inevitable and perfect shape of the truth.
It is magnificent. Majestic. Majestic."

— Thoughts of a K1 researcher meditating in the presence of the Anomaly

Before the Collapse, a Human mining expedition on Luna was commissioned by Clovis Bray I to discover the source of a mysterious signal buried beneath the Moon's crust. Nearly twelve hundred meters deep they discovered a black sphere, whose emissions caused neurochemical cascades that induced intrusive thoughts, insomnia, narcolepsy, nightmares, and auditory and visual hallucinations. The sphere was studied due to an outbound signal that was believed to be connected to a second Traveler, or even the origins of the Traveler. However, the expedition team, despite their best efforts, were eventually driven to madness and perished.

Clovis Bray I later communed with the artifact, which urged him to go to Europa to seek the secret of immortality. He mounted a personal expedition to the icy moon, where he discovered the source of the paracausal power he called "Clarity": an entity he named "Clarity Control".

The Collapse

The Darkness closes in upon the Traveler.

"Something hit us. Killed our Golden Age. Nearly wiped us out. Only the Traveler saved us, and at a shattering cost."

— Grimoire description.

The Collapse was long believed by the Vanguard and the people of the Last City to have been caused by the Darkness itself. In reality, it was brought about by the Black Fleet, led by the Witness and its Disciples, who wielded the Darkness against humanity and the Traveler. During the Collapse, the colony ship Yang Liwei (call sign Exodus Green), was ensnared by the Darkness projected by the Black Fleet as it attempted to escape the Solar System, but was "rescued" by the Traveler projecting a beam of Light to push back the Darkness, which in turn generated a kugelblitz that swallowed the Yang Liwei and transported it and its occupants to a new universe.

Events of Destiny

The Black Heart, an aspect of the Darkness.

Centuries after the Collapse, a lone Guardian encountered the Exo Stranger on Venus and was subsequently sent on a quest to find the Black Garden. After battling through the Sol Divisive Vex and reaching the center of the Garden, the Guardian discovered an entity, the Black Heart, that the Vex seemed to revere as an object of worship. The entity could not attack the Guardian directly but attempted to defend itself by taking control of the Sol Progeny, three enormous Vex Minotaurs. After a protracted battle, the Black Heart was destroyed along with its three Sol Progeny vessels. Upon the defeat of the Black Heart, the Black Garden was relocated to Mars from its prior location, and Light began to return to the dormant and damaged Traveler.

Following the battle in the Black Garden, Ikora Rey hypothesized that the Black Heart had been an aspect of the Darkness itself. It would not be until much later that it was revealed to in fact be an attempt by the Sol Divisive to replicate the Veil, an equally mysterious paracausal entity associated with both the Darkness and the Traveler.

Forsaken

Mara Sov's star map of the Darkness ships.

The Scorn, a faction of undead Fallen first encountered by the Guardians in a mass breakout from the Prison of Elders, were created through the use of Darkness-tainted Ether by Fikrul, the Fanatic. This "Dark Ether" was first generated when Riven drew upon Uldren Sov's internal Darkness and infused it into Ether, bringing Fikrul back from death.

Shadowkeep

"Don't you recognize us? We are not your friend. We are not your enemy. We are your… salvation."

— The Witness

Ikora looking at the Luna Pyramid

Eris Morn, after going missing prior to the Red War, stumbled upon a derelict Pyramid beneath the surface of the Moon that once belonged to Nezarec. She discovered that the Darkness originating from the Pyramid was triggered into unleashing phantasmal Nightmares, and that the Hidden Swarm was harnessing them in a crimson citadel built above the ancient ship, near the Hellmouth, dubbed the Scarlet Keep. With Eris Morn as their guide and having the Vanguard's approval on handling the situation, the Guardians fought the Hive and the Darkness-powered Nightmares. Using the Hive's knowledge and the essence of the most powerful of Nightmares, Eris was able to forge armor that was capable of resisting the Nightmares.

Now prepared and with the Nightmares pushed back, the Young Wolf descended beneath the Scarlet Keep to the Pyramid. There, the Witness possessed the Guardian's Ghost and opened the Pyramid, drawing in the Guardian. Inside, the Guardian faces off against Nightmares of their most dangerous foes: Ghaul, Crota and Fikrul. As they combat the powerful Nightmares, the Witness lectured the Guardians through their Ghost on the Light's failures and weaknesses. Despite this, the Guardian managed to overcome the Nightmares and reach the center of the Pyramid, where a veiled statue stood.

The Guardian received an Unknown Artifact from the statue and was subjected to a vision, in which they stood within the Black Garden and encountered the Witness taking the form of themselves. The Witness addressed the Guardian, saying that it had heard humanity's "cries for help" and that it would soon answer, and stating that it was neither the Guardian's friend nor enemy, but instead their "salvation".

The Guardian brought the Unknown Artifact to Eris and reported what they encountered in the Pyramid to the Vanguard, which they took as confirmation that the force that caused the Collapse was preparing to return. At the same time, Eris identified a signal emitting from the artifact that led deep within the Black Garden, to which a fireteam of Guardians was sent to investigate. They discovered two Axis Minds that seemed to have been warped by an unknown force, the Consecrated Mind and Sanctified Mind, and found another veiled statue identical in shape to the one on the Lunar Pyramid.

The Guardian began receiving messages through the Unknown Artifact, seemingly from the Darkness itself; Eris dismissed the messages as attempts at manipulation, but they provided potentially valuable information into the origin of the Light, the Darkness, the Vex, and the Universe itself.

When Osiris confronted Rasputin regarding his allegiance to the Light or the Darkness, the Warmind directed him to an anomalous signal located in the Kuiper Belt. Upon arriving at the coordinates, Sagira reported feeling strange, like the Guardian's Ghost when approaching the Pyramid. Osiris then entered "an anomalous Maw" and returned with a "cold metal seed" before setting his ship on a course to return to the inner Solar System.

Season of Arrivals

Rasputin shuts down.

"The day we've been dreading has finally arrived. The Darkness is here."

— Commander Zavala

Several days after the Almighty's destruction, the Black Fleet arrived and began to push into the solar system. One Pyramid went to Io, the last place to be touched by the Traveler, and stationed itself over a strange tree that had grown in the center of the Cradle. Using a seed retrieved from beneath the roots of the tree, Eris attempted to communicate with the Darkness, but its messages were distorted by interference from Savathûn. The Guardian managed to repeatedly fight Savathûn's forces back, allowing Eris to receive and interpret the Darkness' messages.

A Pyramid stationed on Mercury

Almost half a year after the Pyramids returned, the worlds of Mercury, Mars, Io, and Titan all disappeared from the system, having been transported to an unknown realm by the Witness using the Darkness.

Beyond Light

The Europa Pyramid silently hovering above the Europan ice fields.

"The Light believes you thankless. Nothing more than a soldier asked again and again to do its bidding.
So we want to thank you. With a gift. To help you finally take control."

— The Witness to the Guardian

Sometime after the initial detection of the Black Fleet by Rasputin, a sixth Pyramid touched down on Europa. It remained unknown to the rest of the system for a time, until Eramis, Kell of Darkness and her newly-formed House of Salvation discovered it hovering over the icy surface of the moon. Using Splinters of Darkness originating from the Pyramid, Eramis attempted to harness the power of Stasis to rebuild the Eliksni Empire and destroy the Traveler.

Subsequently, the Guardian would also be granted the power of Stasis, initially through a Splinter of Darkness and later drawing the power from within themselves. Their Stasis abilities would be magnified by repeated communions with a Ziggurat deployed by the Europan Pyramid.

The Witch Queen

During the Guardian's exploration of Savathûn's Throne World, they encountered pockets of psychic energy which granted them access to Deepsight, a form of clairvoyance enabled by the Darkness.

Lightfall

Following Rasputin's sacrifice to prevent Eramis from using the Warsat network to fire upon the Traveler, the Witness and its Black Fleet advanced on the Traveler. The Pyramids destroyed any craft that attempted to attack using waves of Resonance energy, while the Witness itself used the Darkness to effortlessly slice apart incoming Jumpships and their occupants. The Traveler itself was neutralized by a ring of eight Pyramids that took up formation around it, emitting a concerted wave of Resonance that halted a beam of Light the Traveler had projected to defend itself.

Following the Witness extracting the location of the Veil from the Traveler, Osiris and the Guardian followed Calus and his Shadow Legion to Neptune, where they found the hidden city of Neomuna. Upon touching down in the city, they immediately noticed strands of green energy permeating the local environment, which they discovered to be a new elemental manifestation of Darkness known as Strand. The concentration of Strand energy in the city was a result of the presence of the Veil, itself a powerful paracausal entity seemingly associated with the Darkness.

Season of the Deep

Following Titan's reappearance, the Guardian worked together with Sloane to strengthen her telepathic connection to Ahsa, with whom Sloane had become psychically bonded with through the Darkness. Ikora and Osiris also noted that the Veil's paracausal signature had become stronger after Titan's reappearance, and speculated that the connection between Titan and the Veil could hold a clue in following the Witness.

The Fall of the Witness

This section needs expansion. You can help Destinypedia by expanding it.

The Nature of the Darkness

Because so few survived the Collapse, the exact nature of the Darkness had long been a mystery to most living within the Last City. For centuries, it was said that the Collapse had been brought about by "the Darkness", and that this mysterious force was the enemy of the Traveler. Recent events have clarified that the Collapse was in fact brought about by the Witness and the Black Fleet and that the Darkness is a paracausal force wielded by them, much as the Light is distinct from the Traveler.

Theories and Speculation

In the centuries following the Collapse, several theories as to what the Darkness actually is were proposed by various scholars among the Guardians and other people of the City. The most well-known of these are listed below:

• Pujari claimed that the Darkness is both a physical and moral presence, evil made tangible. It was a storm of corruption emerging from the Golden Age. Also known as the Pujari Position, it is one of two doctrines that was widely popular at the Tower and the City at large.

• Saint-14 argued that the Darkness was an invading armada of aliens. Some suggest that these aliens had been previously rejected by the Traveler for their sins. In reality, the most likely explanation is the Fallen. His position stood as the most eminently practical of public opinions in the City.

• Ulan-Tan suggests that the Darkness is the necessary symmetry to the Traveler as part of a cosmic balance. The Symmetry faction also follows in his beliefs.

• The Monists believe the Darkness is a technologically superior force, to the point of post-singularity, and that the universe is just a simulation. Such an advanced intelligence could mimic acausality by bending the rules of the universe's programming.

• The Acataleptic Clause, and the Praxic Order, believe that not only is the Darkness unknowable, but that people shouldn't bother trying to understand it and instead simply fight it. It is one of two doctrines that were widely popular at the Tower and the City alongside the Pujari Position.

• A heretical position from the Binary Star Cult states that the Traveler itself triggered the collapse, and used humanity as a sacrifice/proxy army in its war against the Darkness.

It is now known that most of these proposed explanations are actually true to some extent: the Darkness is a paracausal force that is the counterpart to the Light, it is closely associated with a philosophy that most would consider deeply immoral or evil, and its principal wielders and servants are the Witness and its Disciples, a collective of aliens that at least in part were abandoned by the Traveler and make use of supremely advanced technology in the form of the Pyramids.

Toland's Understanding

Toland, the Shattered understands the Darkness as the natural evolutionary endpoint of the entire universe. Since the beginning of time, everything has competed with everything else for no reason, other than that is the way of the universe: the law of the jungle. As atoms came into being, they defeated the "primordial broth" that preceded it. From atoms came stars, from stars came galaxies, worlds were created, and finally life arose, all due to the eternal competition.

Toland envisions a future where three archetypal "nations" compete with each other: the first represents the perfect rule of law, the second represents knowledge made paramount, and the third represents sheer, total conquest. The third nation will succeed, inevitably, and in time will lead to a greater conflict between other nations which all represent the desire to conquer and dominate. The universe thus becomes a place where only the most ruthless entities succeed, to the point where they actively hunt and exterminate other life long before it can ever be a true threat. Finally, at the end of time, there will be only one entity that rules the universe so absolutely that nothing will ever exist except by its consent, so it will rule forever. In essence, Toland asserts that this incontestable supremacy is the goal or driving force of the Darkness.

An alternative way of life, where law and knowledge might work together rather than compete, as in the case of humanity and the City, is little more than "the dream of small minds", and is unlikely to succeed against an entity of pure conquest.

Rasputin's Testimony

"This is a SKYSHOCK ALERT.
Multiple distributed ISR assets report a TRANSIENT NEAR EXTRASOLAR EVENT. Event duration ZERO POINT THREE SECONDS. Event footprint includes sterile neutrino scattering and gravity waves. Omnibus analysis detects deep structure information content (nine sigma) and internal teleonomy.
No hypothesis on event mechanism (FLAG ACAUSAL). Bootstrap simulation suggests event is DIRECTED and INIMICABLE (convergent q-Bayes/Monte Carlo probability approaches 1)."

— Rasputin

Rasputin monitoring the Pyramid Fleet.

The Warmind Rasputin was among the first beings in the Sol System to become aware of the arrival of the Black Fleet immediately prior to the Collapse. Given the unknown nature of the threat at the time, it remains unclear to what degree Rasputin's observations apply to the Black Fleet, the Darkness itself, or both. In any case, measurements taken by Rasputin indicated that the unknown phenomenon was accompanied by sterile neutrinos and gravity waves, seemed to have a structured intelligence and purpose behind its actions, and did not fully obey the known laws of physics. Using the minimal data that he had, Rasputin concluded that the force was hostile and capable of an interplanetary extinction event, causing him to activate defensive protocols and send messages to his subminds to prepare for an imminent attack.

Dreams of Alpha Lupi

The Dreams of Alpha Lupi poem contains a verse related to the Darkness and possibly representative of the Darkness's own perspective. The verse explains that the universe, despite its vastness, is beholden to simple, enduring laws that shape it and give one the impression that it is inexhaustible and eternal. Life is an affront to the universe because it refuses to accept the limitations imposed on it by the natural order.

Ghost Fragment: Darkness 4

Ghost Fragment: Darkness 4 contains an excerpt of unknown origin, addressing an unknown recipient. Its opening line: "This war is all there is for you." is also a line of dialog, spoken by Future War Cult representative Lakshmi-2, in which she asks the player what they would do if, "on some dreadful night, the Darkness were to come creeping up" and whisper the aforementioned statement to them. This would suggest that the excerpt in Ghost Fragment: Darkness 4 is the full text of that opening statement, indicating that the Darkness is addressing a Guardian, attempting to entice them into turning away from the Light, or at least plant the seeds of doubt.

The Books of Sorrow

Auryx faces the Worm God, Akka

"Out in the world we ask a simple, true question. A question like, can I kill you, can I rip your world apart? Tell me the truth. For if I don't ask, someone will ask it of me.
And they call us evil. Evil! Evil means 'socially maladaptive.' We are adaptiveness itself."

— The Darkness

Following the arrival of Oryx, the Taken King in the Sol System, a series of records known as the Books of Sorrow were discovered aboard Oryx's Dreadnaught that provided new insight into the nature of the Darkness. According to these records, on one occasion Oryx went deep into the Ascendant Realm using the Tablets of Ruin and prepared an unborn Ogre, which he used as a vessel to summon and communicate with what he claimed to have been the Darkness itself.

In the conversation that followed, the Darkness portrayed itself as a manifestation or embodiment of the universal struggle for existence: whereas the Traveler seeks to nurture civilization by encouraging peace and mutual cooperation, the Darkness is dedicated to the annihilation of all beings and civilizations who do not possess the strength to survive in the face of conquest. Its eventual goal is to bring about a universe inhabited solely by those entities who have survived by defeating all opposition. To this end, it has destroyed countless planets and civilizations, either through direct action or through its disciples, such as the Hive.

Relation to Simplicity, Emotion and Memory

The Darkness is associated with simplification and the removal of extraneous entities; in contrast, the Light appears to be associated with the "growth and preservation of complexity". In keeping with this, the Darkness is often associated with triangles and tetrahedrons, whereas the Light is associated with circles and spheres.

Clovis Bray I studied the Darkness during the late Golden Age, having been exposed to it through the K1 Anomaly and later through the entity he called "Clarity Control." In his notes, he observed that the Darkness violated Noether's theorem, and did not follow established physical rules of symmetry and conservation. He also noted that the Darkness possessed "anti-structural" properties, and had a tendency to reduce the entropy of systems it was applied to, leading him to hypothesize that it may have been responsible for the low-entropy state of the universe preceding the Big Bang.

Following the discovery of Strand, Osiris states that the Darkness is associated with thoughts and consciousness, whereas the Light is tied more strongly to the physical universe. The nature of Strand, Deepsight and Nightmares all reflect this connection; Stasis crystals have also been noted to exhibit computational properties, potentially supporting simulation or even cognition within themselves. This may also explain the Darkness' association with the Ascendant Realm, as the latter is a dimension whose nature is heavily influenced by thoughts and beliefs.

As an extension of this theme, the Darkness is associated with memory, whereas the Light is associated with forgetting. This is exemplified by Deepsight, which allows one to, among other things, experience memories associated with an object's past. In contrast, when the Light is first bestowed upon an individual via resurrection by a Ghost, they forget all details of their past life. The Hidden agent Sen-Aret hypothesizes that the Darkness connects individuals with the past so that they may strategize defenses against threats they have previously encountered, whereas the Light wipes away memories in order to enable forgiveness and the possibility of new beginnings. The manifestation of Darkness known as Resonance also seems to be connected to memory and emotion, as shown when the Qugu fleet drew upon the fury of their ancestors using the Darkness to manifest a Resonant blast in their final stand against a Pyramid of the Black Fleet.

This dichotomy was further highlighted when the Witness entered the Traveler's Pale Heart, as it attempted to use the Traveler's Light to bring its vision of the Final Shape into reality; the Final Shape existed as a concept within the Darkness, but the Witness needed the Light to enforce its ideas upon the physical universe.

The Winnower

"It is the nature of life to favor existence over nonexistence, and to prefer the fertile soil to the poisoned wind. Because those who open their mouths to that wind pass from the world and leave no descendant, whether of flesh or of thought.
But imagine the abomination of a world where nothing can end and no choice can be preferred to any other. Imagine the things that would suffer and never die. Imagine the lies that would flourish without context or corrective. Imagine a world without me."

— Unveiling

Several obscure entries contain statements attributed to an entity referred to as "the Winnower," which appears to be either synonymous with or the source of Darkness itself; the true nature of this entity remains mysterious and contentious at present.

During their exploration of the Lunar Pyramid, the Guardian received an unknown artifact from the Witness which relayed a series of messages addressed to the Guardian by the Winnower, which presented itself as one of two cosmic entities or forces which gave rise to the universe, alongside its opposing counterpart the "Gardener". The Witness acknowledged the Winnower as a separate entity shortly before its destruction at the hands of the Coalition, stating that it was not the Winnower, but merely "the first knife clutched in its hand" . The name "Winnower" was also used by Ahsa when she recounted the origin of the Witness to the Guardian, referring to the Veil.

In the messages received by the Guardian and translated by Eris Morn, the Winnower states itself to be one of two primordial entities who predate the universe, the other being the Gardener. The Winnower is presented as embodying the reduction of complexity, whereas the Gardener embodies the growth and preservation of complexity. In the allegorical story recounted by the Winnower, these two entities struggled with one another in the state which preceded the multiverse, and upon inadvertently creating the multiverse as a by-product of this struggle, each became a paracausal force which would serve to further their respective goals within its many universes. The Winnower claims to have subsequently influenced the evolution of life throughout the cosmos, stating that it was responsible for the Cambrian Explosion that gave rise to complex animal life on Earth, and thus the evolution of humanity. This story not only appears to provide an origin for the Light and Darkness as they are presently known, but also implies that the Darkness is itself sentient and has its own motivations, exerting its influence on reality in various subtle ways so as to guide the universe toward an eternal, maximally simplified form known as the Final Shape.

The unnamed narrator of the entry "Winnowing" in the Lore Book Inspiral writes in a similar style and tone as the Winnower in Unveiling, and the entry itself appears to reference and elaborate slightly on the information presented in the previous Lore Book. The narrator of the entry describes how a garden requires both a gardener to care for its plants, and a winnower to prune away excess growth and rot; if there is no winnower to do the pruning, the plants will be forced to do it themselves lest the garden deteriorate. Much as with Unveiling, this description appears to be allegorical, and seems to suggest that both the Darkness and Light are necessary to maintain the stability of life and civilization within the universe; as the narrator states, "there can be no gardens without knives".

Following the revelation that the Witness and its Black Fleet were behind the Collapse and other historical events once attributed to the Darkness itself, and the discovery that Stasis and Strand could be wielded by Guardians without inevitably leading to moral corruption, the Vanguard has for the most part come to regard the Darkness as a neutral force, without any form of guiding intent or moral connotations associated with its use . Similarly, various statements once ascribed to the Darkness have since been recontextualized as instead originating from the Witness, which was referred to by Mara Sov as "the Voice in the Darkness". After reading Unveiling, Ikora Rey stated that messages were in fact narrated by the Witness, which it had deceitfully presented itself as a "monolithic cosmic force"; however, in a later conversation with Mara Sov, she wondered whether the texts were in fact a shadow of the truth, in which the Witness was merely a pawn of some other force.

Aspects and Manifestations

Much like the Light manifests itself in varying forms such as Arc, Void and Solar Light, the Darkness also manifests in a variety of ways that can be wielded by its users.

During his studies of Strand, Osiris hypothesized that the appearance and nature of "elemental" manifestations of Darkness such as Stasis and Strand may be shaped by the thoughts and preconceptions of their wielders; for example, he suggested that the string-like nature of Strand might be a result of the Guardian forming a subconscious association between the idea of "connection" and physical strings, and hypothesized that it might have instead appeared to the Neomuni as "cosmic water" had they discovered it first, as a result of their cultural beliefs regarding the "river of souls".

Stasis

Main article: Stasis

Stasis is an elemental aspect of the Darkness that enables its wielders to freeze objects by halting the motion of their constituent particles.

Strand

Main article: Strand

Strand is an elemental aspect of the Darkness that enables its wielders to manifest threads of psychic energy.

Resonance

The Witness, its Disciples, and various artifacts of the Black Fleet wield or emit a form of Darkness referred to as "Resonance", characterized by an orange glow with topological aesthetics and spiraling helices of black angular shapes. The Qugu also were capable of using Resonance, as seen when the Qugu fleet called upon the memories and fury of their ancestors to manifest a massive Resonant blast that destroyed a Pyramid; this seems to indicate that Resonance is tied to memory and emotion.

Taking

Main article: Taken

"Taking involves reforming matter in a self-contained reality, where the creator defines past, present, and future; imagine how a more insightful being could expand these definitions, to different ends. Overcoming a target's will must consume a large portion of energy. What if you used that energy for larger shifts in reality? You could teleport an army into a Hive mothership… move a fleet outside time and space… perhaps even alter a moon's orbit, devastating the planet below. The military applications could be far graver than simply creating an army."

— Ophiuchus

The Darkness can be used to displace beings from the "normal" universe into the Ascendant Realm, allowing them to be subsequently corrupted into Taken through an unknown process. It appears that this is only one specific application of a broader power, as the Witness has demonstrated the ability to move entire planets between dimensions, as well as temporally shift selected regions of a planet into different points in time.

Deepsight

Main article: Deepsight

Deepsight is a form of clairvoyance that allows one to see through illusions and perceive echoes of past events. It is predominately used to uncover memories like those within the Court of Savathûn and crafting weapons with from the Relic.

Nightmares

Main article: Nightmare

Nightmares surrounding the Luna Pyramid

Nightmares are apparitions created using the Darkness, usually manifesting to a given individual as someone whose memory is associated with fear, regret or other emotional trauma. It is believed that this application of the Darkness was first discovered by Nezarec, Final God of Pain, who later wove Nightmares into his Pyramid as a security system. Like Deepsight, this power is thematically in keeping with the Darkness' association with memory and consciousness.

Egregore

Main article: Egregore

According to Eris Morn, the fungus-like lifeform known as egregore is a manifestation of Darkness in a similar manner as Stasis, but "impure" in some way.

Darkness Fields

Based on matching descriptions from Emperor Calus, the Hive, Cayde-6, and Awoken records, certain Darkness-related entities seem to have the ability to project a field that gives the impression of complete darkness surrounding an individual. Calus wrote that upon encountering the Black Fleet, it initially appeared as a complete void to him, while the crew of the Yang Liwei reported being surrounded by a force that "made the stars go out" after their ship was confronted by a Pyramid; Osiris similarly described a Pyramid as being surrounded by a "maw" of darkness when he sought out the Black Fleet beyond the edge of the Heliopause. During the Collapse, Cayde-6 described being enveloped by a smothering, paralyzing black cloud, however, in this case, it left his senses intact so that he could witness the destruction of his surroundings. Similar smothering miasmas of Darkness have been encountered by Guardians in areas where the Darkness is entrenched, such as the Disciple's Bog in Savathûn's Throne World.

Following the Collapse, areas of planets became blasted by the Darkness so badly that it made it impossible for the Light to shine there, and for Ghosts to resurrect their Guardians.

The Drifter also encountered mysterious entities on an unknown, distant ice world that were trapped in alien monoliths. These beings had a disturbing ability to kill Ghosts from just being near them and nullify Light itself. The beings were everywhere on the world, and were described as having a "Darkness field." The Suppressor devices used by the Shadow Legion during the invasion of Neomuna were similarly able to inhibit the Light-based abilities of Guardians, as are some forms of Dread such as Grim and Tormentors.

Influences

The Witness and its Precursors

The precursor species that gave rise to the Witness is the oldest known species to have encountered and wielded the Darkness. Eons after discovering the Traveler, the precursors found the Veil in a distant star system, and sought to use its Darkness in combination with the Traveler's Light to bring about a "Final Shape" for the universe. Afterward, they used the Darkness of the Veil to merge the consciousnesses of their entire species into the Witness.

Guardians

"You are the gardener's final argument. It would mean everything if I could convince you that I am the right and only way.
I truly value you. To the gardener, you are a means to an end. To me, you are majestic. Majestic. You are full of the only thing worth anything at all.
I am, by the only standard that matters or will ever matter, the winning team. Existence is a test that most will fail. Would you not count yourself among the victorious few?
Don't hurry to deliver your answer. I'll come over and hear it myself."

— The narrator of Unveiling

Guardians wielding the Dark powers of Stasis

According to Unveiling, the Darkness desires to sway the Guardians to its philosophy, as it acknowledges them as beings powerful enough to potentially become the "final shape" it wishes to bring about.

There are a handful of Guardians who have been corrupted by the Darkness, the most infamous being Dredgen Yor. Yor came to desire taking innocent lives and sowing despair, claiming he had developed a hunger for it. Toland, the Shattered claimed to be able to communicate with the Darkness, whereas Eris Morn was able to survive and escape the Hellmouth wielding the very power she fought against. Eris had one time even used the power of Darkness to rescue the Guardian from being trapped in the Oversoul Throne.

As of recently, many Guardians have come to wield the Darkness in the form of Stasis and Strand, and utilize its abilities such as Deepsight to reveal hidden secrets and shape weapons from memory. According to Osiris, the key to wielding the Darkness properly is to have the right perspective, such as a sense of self-discipline to use Stasis or a proactive, open mindset to use Strand.

Ghosts

With certain modifications, Ghosts can access the Darkness as well as the Light; the Drifter's Ghost became attuned to the Darkness after being modified with parts scavenged from other Ghosts. The Witness was also capable of overriding Ghosts and using them as conduits for communication, although it is unclear whether this ability stemmed from its use of the Darkness or the Light, or some other power at its disposal.

Eliksni

Eramis, Kell of Darkness with the Splinter of Darkness

"What others call dark which is not I know what it is but no time room calm given for an appropriate telling so I say only that what is not shadow is an ally and a wonder and I respect what I cannot steal from and you cannot take from the dark you can claim only pain from the dark and that is why the dark is worthy of love beyond all other love that astonishing ability to evade being robbed."

— Ghost Fragment: Fallen 2

The Eliksni civilization was destroyed when the Black Fleet attacked Riis and the Traveler fled, an event known as the Whirlwind. A reclaimed (though corrupted) Fallen story mentions that the Fallen respect what they cannot steal from, which is "why the dark is worthy of love beyond all other love that astonishing ability to evade being robbed".

Sometime around the events of Shadowkeep, Guardians were introduced to Fallen Champions who had been "touched" by the Darkness and given powerful abilities to fight back against their foes. Usually they are seen in high-leveled endgame content such as Nightfalls and recently Raids.

Later, Eramis would proclaim herself as the Kell of Darkness of the House of Salvation and led the newly formed House to Europa to acquire the powers of the Darkness. They began utilizing the Darkness as a means to destroy the Guardians and The Last City, going against the Fallen's traditions and ideals by willingly using the very thing that destroyed their home. With her newfound power, she began plotting to rebuild their Eliksni civilization and take vengeance against the Traveler for abandoning her people centuries prior.

Scorn

The resurrecting Fikrul the Fanatic

"We… are alike. Trapped in death… a never-ending dance."

— Fikrul, the Fanatic

The Scorn are a horde of undead Fallen created through the use of Ether infused with Darkness. Originally born from a distorted wish granted to Uldren Sov by the Taken Ahamkara Riven, the Scorn display the ability to resurrect, even multiple times, though their minds seemingly degrade with each return. They were originally led by Fikrul, the Fanatic, a heretical Archon and first in their number, but since his disappearance, they have been seen under the control of other powerful Darkness entities, like the Disciples of the Witness and Xivu Arath, God of War. The Witness itself seems capable of resurrecting dead Eliksni into more Scorn, which has been used as punishment for Eramis's repeated failures.

Scorn under this new leadership enjoy access to powerful Pyramid technology, which allows many of them to rise to the power of their deceased Barons, and perhaps even surpass them. However, despite their power, all Scorn are often fully enslaved to the entity controlling them, incapable of expressing original thoughts. When abandoned without a guide, they follow whatever order was given to them last, which usually brings them to repeat their violence on others in an endless loop.

Cabal

The Cabal had some texts on their athenaeum worlds that theorized about the Darkness, with the little concrete information the texts contained about the Darkness having been recorded from the "dreams of worms".

Zavala, Osiris, and Cabal talking about the Darkness

During his exile, the former emperor Calus sought the means to defeat his usurper Ghaul by exploring the secret places of the galaxy and pushing the limits of reason once he regains control of the Leviathan. He eventually crossed paths with a perfect void at the edge of the universe, being the Witness and the Black Fleet, and resolved to become its herald. He would watch them consume the light of the universe, and all among the last of the living would know his greatness. Calus also knows of the pact that Oryx made with the Worms, comparing it to Ghaul's takeover of the legions. Calus' strange powers and his claims of "knowing the truth" about the galaxy and his mockery of the Guardians' "feeble light" imply that he may have some knowledge of the Darkness.

At some point, Red Legion Psions used their psionic powers to successfully harness and infuse Taken energy into themselves and their superiors, empowering them with Taken-enhanced shielding. However, this effort was stopped by The Guardian.

During the Season of Dawn, the Guardians had faced Cabal Champions who were "touched" by the Darkness and were given newfound abilities. Soon they were frequently encountered at high-leveled endgame content, most notably Nightfalls.

During Season of the Haunted, Calus would return to Sol two years later, now the newest Disciple of the Witness. He would succeed in merging his consciousness with the Lunar Pyramid, however, he would be stopped by The Coalition who would sever his connection with the pyramid.

Calus alongside his new army the Shadow Legion would arrive in Sol alongside The Witness. The Shadow Legion have access to powerful Pyramid technology and are assisted by Tormentors among their ranks. They are said to be filled with emptiness and follow orders without question. The Shadow Legion are described by Empress Caiatl as not knowing what it is like to be Cabal when their attempt to recreate the Rite of Proving failed.

Hive

Darkness calling out the Hive, Fallen, and Cabal

The Hive revere the Darkness and serve the Witness. The progenitors of the Hive made a pact with their highest gods, the Worms, who grant the powers of Darkness to the Hive. The Hive god Oryx, the Taken King stole the power of the Darkness from his patron deity, Akka, the Worm of Secrets, which allowed him to wield the Darkness and create Taken. The Hive religion, based around the 'Sword-Logic', is based upon the Darkness' philosophy of survival-of-the-fittest and power through conquest.

Vex

Sanctified Mind defending a Pyramid Scale.

"In all their transformations, they retained that kernel of ultimate self-sufficiency that had made them victors in the flower game.
But they are not incontrovertibly destined to rule this cosmos. They were made before Light and Darkness, but the rules are different now, and even this pattern must adapt.
They are not all mine, not in the way that admirers such as my man Oryx are mine: utterly devoted to the practice of my principle. But some of them have, nonetheless, found their way home."

— The narrator of Unveiling

The majority of the Vex avoid the Darkness, due to a combination of their inability to simulate paracausality and the fact that their ultimate goal of Convergence (an end state of the universe where only the Vex exist) means that they would have to overcome the Darkness. The Vex of the Sol Divisive however, worship the Black Heart, an aspect of the Darkness.Osiris theorized that some Vex technology is tuned to react to the presence of the Darkness.

Through unknown means, the Sol Inherent, a powerful subdivision of the Sol Divisive, appear to have been exposed to the Darkness and changed by it somehow, causing them to take on malformed, organic, visceral appearances. Upon the deactivation of the Sanctified Mind, a structure behind it opens up to reveal a statue identical to the one found on the Pyramid, hidden by a geometrical platform above which floats a Pyramid Scale. The significance of this is unknown.

During the events of Shadowkeep, Guardians faced Vex Champions who have been "touched" by the Darkness and were given newfound abilities to be on par against their powerful adversaries.They were later encountered in high-level content such as Nightfalls.

Awoken & Jovians

The Emissary showing the Drifter the Darkness fleet

The Awoken were once humans but were transformed during the Collapse upon reaching the edge of the asteroid belt. Beyond the belt, "the edge of the Deep Black", the system is totally immersed in Darkness. The events of their transformation were further detailed in the Lore book "Marasenna", which reveals that the Awoken were captured in a kugelblitz formed by the Darkness and Light battling one another in the vicinity of the Yang Liwei. As a result of this event, the Awoken were reborn as beings containing both Light and Darkness within themselves.

During his possession by the Taken Ahamkara known as Riven, Uldren Sov emitted streams of Darkness from his eyes to activate the gate of the Dreaming City.

Taken

Oryx demonstrating the power to Take

As demonstrated by the Witness and Oryx, the Taken King the Darkness can be used to take direct possession of other beings, transforming them into Taken. When a being is Taken, they are warped into the Ascendant Plane, where they are reshaped into spectral ghost-like versions of their former selves, with new paracausal abilities and a single-minded dedication to the one that Took them.

Ecumene

The Ecumene were attuned to the Darkness, and this connection formed a central part of their culture.

Qugu

The Qugu were attuned to the Darkness, and could access the memories of their ancestors through it.

Trivia

• The Darkness bears resemblance to the Armies of the Dark and its leader in Bungie's Myth series—a resurgent dark force that is the antithesis to the (forces of) Light.
• The idea of the Darkness arising from a primordial universe bears resemblance to the origins of the W'rkncacnter from Bungie's Marathon series.
• The tetrahedral shapes often seen in association with the Darkness allude to the philosophy of the Darkness, as presented in the Books of Sorrow and Unveiling; tetrahedrons are the simplest possible three-dimensional shape, and the Darkness seeks to reduce the universe into a maximally simplified, eternal form. Notably, the Pyramids of the Black Fleet are themselves tetrahedrons, with each face being either a right, isosceles or regular triangle. In contrast, the Traveler is a sphere, which can be described as having infinitely many faces; this may allude to the philosophy of the Light, which encourages complexity and diversity.
• A teaser released on the official Destiny 2 Twitter page on the 29th of May 2020 features a 1:13 long video that plays audio that seems to fit the nature of the Darkness. The Video also features a typical soundbar background but the bars do not move in time with the audio itself, instead, they are frozen with some of the bars forming the shape of a small pyramid and a large pyramid. At the end of Season of Arrivals, it was revealed that these sounds were the ambience for the pillar room. Many of these sounds were reused for the Europan Pyramid's interior, mixed with the pulsing from the Lunar Pyramid.
• The theme that accompanies the Darkness and the Pyramids contains seven notes.
• The Lore entry of Nacre, written by an anonymous entity, uses a similar tone as that used by the speaker in Unveiling and "Majestic. Majestic"; the speaker in Nacre also references "my sedimentary necrolite, frozen in time," which appears to reference the Witness' failed vision of the Final Shape, whether or not the speaker is the Darkness/Winnower is unconfirmed.
• In various Lore entries, entities associated with the Darkness are described as giving off the smell of petrichor or wet soil. The significance of this, if any, is unknown.

Gallery

• 

  The Grimoire's image for the Darkness.

• 

  Concept art of a Darkness construct.

• 

  The Darkness consuming a human.

• 

  Concept art of the Darkness race.

• 

  Disturbing concept art of a human drowning in Darkness.

• 

  A Ghost drowning in Darkness.

• 

  The Darkness traveling across water.

• 

  The Darkness affecting a human's form.

List of appearances

• Destiny (First appearance)
• Cayde's Treasure Island Book (Mentioned only)
• Destiny 2
• Destiny: Fall of Osiris (Mentioned only)
• Destiny Grimoire Anthology, Volume I (Mentioned only)
• Mysterious Logbook (Mentioned only)
• Destiny Grimoire Anthology, Volume III (Mentioned only)
• The Hidden Dossier (Mentioned only)
• Bitter (Mentioned only)
• Entelechy (Mentioned only)
• Destiny Grimoire Anthology, Volume VII (Mentioned only)