Talk:Atraks-1, Fallen Exo: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 13:07, October 17, 2024

Atraks-Corrupted Puppeteer explanation[edit]

For the sake of editors like me attempting to reconcile the whole discussion/dispute of Atraks-1 being The Corrupted Puppeteer, I figured we are owed a deep dive explaining the rationale why this wikia cannot recognize it. If not, this will only lead to confusion on part of newer editors. StanNPractice (talk) 13:39, October 17, 2024 (EDT)

Just because they share the same in-game model is not implicit or even explicit evidence they are the same character. It’s Bungie reusing assets. Destinypedia has long since known about these oversights or inconsistencies since before I joined this wiki.
Destinypedia is not a speculative forum. We are not in the business of speculation; we only record what we see. Mentioning that The Corrupted Puppeteer shares a model with Atraks-1, Fallen Exo is okay; trying to use that as justification they are the same character or that one is inspired by the other is against Destinypedia’s rules.
We have forums, including Forum:Fan Fiction, where you can write your own fanfic about this and that regarding Destiny. They exist precisely for this reason. Leave it out of mainspace articles. —Δαντε τηε Γηοστ ^{Ι ωονδερ ιφ Ικορα γιϝες ηυγς το Γηοστσ. Ηεη... ανψωαψς, νιξε ωορκ. Τηις ις ωηατ Ι υσεδ.} 14:07, October 17, 2024 (EDT)

@@ Line 3: / Line 3: @@
 For the sake of editors like me attempting to reconcile the whole discussion/dispute of Atraks-1 being [[The Corrupted Puppeteer]], I figured we are owed a deep dive explaining the rationale why this wikia cannot recognize it. If not, this will only lead to confusion on part of newer editors.
 [[User:StanNPractice|StanNPractice]] ([[User talk:StanNPractice|talk]]) 13:39, October 17, 2024 (EDT)
+:# Just because they share the same in-game model is not implicit or even explicit evidence they are the same character. It’s Bungie reusing assets. Destinypedia has long since known about these oversights or inconsistencies since before I joined this wiki.
+:# [[Destinypedia:What_Destinypedia_is_not#Destinypedia_is_not_a_speculative_forum|Destinypedia is not a speculative forum]]. We are not in the business of speculation; we only record what we see. Mentioning that The Corrupted Puppeteer shares a model with [[Atraks-1, Fallen Exo]] is okay; trying to use that as justification they are the same character or that one is inspired by the other is against Destinypedia’s rules.
+:# We have forums, including [[Forum:Fan Fiction]], where you can write your own fanfic about this and that regarding Destiny. They exist precisely for this reason. Leave it out of mainspace articles. —{{User:Dante the Ghost/Sig}} 14:07, October 17, 2024 (EDT)